I started going out with him when I was fifteen. I was young and naive. I knew nothing about being gay; we didn't have a television and I didn't have much exposure to popular culture, even what little there was at the time about gay issues. I read mostly religous publications.
And yet my gaydar went off immediately when I met him. I just didn't know what to make of it.
I remember it pretty clearly. I was being introduced to a room full of people, and I was making mental notes: "she's got brown hair, and he's got a beard, and he's gay, and she's wearing glasses..."
I didn't really know what it meant to be gay, but that was the word I put on him without any thought whatsoever. (I might have mentioned that I've always considered him pretty flaming.) It went by quickly; I didn't have time to put any thought into why I assumed that.
I had a boyfriend at the time, but that didn't last long; it was a long-distance thing that we'd continued from Bible camp. Besides, I was really having fun spending time with this new guy, who did not appear to be morally degenerate at all.
He was, however, flaming. My brothers mocked him mercilessly behind his back. So did I, at times. A person might be "queer, but not as queer as Steve; nobody's as queer as Steve." By this, we meant the person was prim, effeminate, lisping, and quite likely morally degenerate.
Now, you must bear in mind that we didn't have a very good sense of what it meant to be morally degenerate. I am not sure I could name even one activity that I supposed degenerate folks participated in. (Pity that; it might be fun to have a "naughty list" right about now.) In any case, Ex appeared to like me, and I liked him, and he was clearly not degenerate; he was a churchgoing fellow. He was even something of an up-and-coming leader in the church. I put the "gay" label out of my head. It wasn't as if I knew any gay people anyway.
(It turned out that I knew quite a few gay people; most of my male friends from high school came out immediately after graduation. But that is another story. Or at least I hope it is.)
It wasn't until about ten years later that I realised the truth, and by then we were married with a baby, and I'd quit my job at our national broadcaster. Even then, I wrestled with what it meant. He swore up and down he would never leave us to "go and be gay with someone", as I remember sobbing.
He was right; he never did that.
So yes, I knew. And no, I didn't know. And this might only make sense in the context of small religious communities in the mid-nineties.